Reduced orchestrations
I promised to talk about the reduced orchestration we’ll be using for this project and I thought I’d take advantage in a bit of a lull in activities over Easter to do just that.
Verdi’s original orchestration calls for around 55 players: 11 woodwind, 16 brass (including 8 trumpets and one, virtually obsolete, ophicleide), 2 percussion players and let’s say around 25-30 strings to balance them. It’s a big band, and impractical for a lot of amateur choral societies to employ.
Because of the popularity of the work, however, there are other options available. I’m aware of three freely available alternative orchestrations, although I have no doubt there are others out there, and presumably many more if you count arrangements made for specific events but not otherwise actively promoted.
David Meacock, founder of the A40 Choir has made many orchestrations and arrangements including both The Dream of Gerontius and the Verdi. His approach is probably more suited to a performance in a large church or cathedral as it substitutes organ for all the wind players, as well as cutting down on the number of brass and percussion required.
What about the offstage trumpet effect in the Dies Irae? I hear you cry. In an ingenious move, Meacock explains that “The effect can be imitated to a degree by hanging a deep pile rug or thick winter coat over the back of a chair near the music stand, and placing the trumpet’s bell very close to the material so as to produce a muffled sound.” I love the idea of the last trump being played into the back of an old duffle coat.
The composer and arranger Rowland Lee, an old friend, also has a version. This uses scored for 6 woodwind, 7 brass, percussion and strings, and I’m sure would be ideal for those looking for a scaled-down version but with, as near as possible, the original sounds.
In this performance we will be using a fairly new version by Ian Bauers, an arranger who has made a speciality of this type of work, having already completed versions of The Creation, The Seasons, Elijah, and Mozart’s Requiem. He has taken the lightest touch of the three, mainly just reducing the requirements for the wind players. His version requires 6 woodwind, 9 brass, percussion and strings (we’re using 8 first violins, 6 seconds, 4 violas, 4 cellos and 2 double basses) – 41 players in total. It’s still a big band and will make a stupendous noise when required, but it’s more affordable, and means that we may have a fighting chance of fitting all the performers onto the stage (we hope). I’ve heard a recording made a the first performance of this version and I have to say that it’s been cleverly done and the differences will certainly not be apparent to most listeners.




